You are missed with such an intensity that
makes you even more present. In all of our
minds, in all of our hearts. It's your
absence that makes your strength, your
kindness and your impressive dedication to
people and to humanity so incredibly present.
You are missed as a symbol of the struggle
for justice, and for the value of each
individual, the value of especially those
people who seem to have been forgotten.
You are missed in this world. Vik, I miss
you in my world. I miss you as my best friend,
as the one who was always there in the last
year, in good and bad times. You once told me
I should smile, because my smile would light
you. But Vik, it was you who made me laugh.
Not only by your great sense of humor, but
through your unique way to make the world
around you a little brighter, just by being
there. Everybody who knew you knows that,
even those who met you even just once.
You cast a spell on people, through your
charisma, through your personality, through
your warmth. The world has become a bit
darker without you, and it is also my own
little world that has become a bit darker
through your absence.
And Gaza of course, which I cant
imagine without you, probably no one here can
imagine it without you yet. Your Arabic
vocabulary of: Mushkile? Leeesh? Mish
Mushkile! Yallah! was completely enough to
brighten up the people around you, and to
make everyone in Gaza your rafiq and your
rafiqa.
And people in Gaza have loved you and
appreciated you, you knew that and you would
never have thought anything else. We were all
touched and overwhelmed by the grief and
sympathy your death has caused. A compassion
that has helped all of us to overcome our
initial shock, I want to heartily thank you
all for that.
Adie, my friend and ISM colleague once said,
being as ISM in Gaza doesnt only mean
to support the people here, but to be a bit
of a Palestinian yourself, and to join
carrying the burden for a little way. To not
only feel with the pain of others, but to
feel for yourself what it means to lose a
loved one. Because being Palestinian means
losing people you love.
Whoever is behind this senseless, cruel
murder, he reached exactly the opposite of
what he intended. Vik, through your death, we
all have become Palestinians. We are more
determined than ever. We will go on, and we
will continue to fight, in the spirit of your
humanity and with the strength and
steadfastness of the Palestinians.
Not only because you would have wanted us
to, but because we couldnt do anything
else. Not the people out there that you have
inspired and woken up, and not us here, being
united in the same dream, in the same goal
for which we fight: a free Gaza, a free
Palestine.
I remember one morning in autumn. The day
before had been a black day for Gaza, and so
we were all together the whole night, sitting
in the ISM office and writing. Vik and I left
at dawn. And just as we had walked a few
steps, it started to rain. The first rain of
the year. And we stood in the middle of the
road, feeling the rain pouring down upon us,
and laughed, and suddenly it was as if the
whole sadness of the last hours was washed
away. As if it was a new beginning, in which
the world was pure and innocent and full of
hope.
I will not grieve because I know that
where you went, there was such a morning
waiting for you. I will not grieve, in
gratitude of having gotten to know you.
Because people like you show us that also for
our humanity there could be such a morning
waiting for us."
?
PRESS RELEASE: ISM COMMITTED TO STAYING
IN GAZA
ISM GAZA
Following the murder of our comrade and
friend Vittorio, we, activists
of the International Solidarity Movement,
reiterate our commitment to
remaining in Gaza. We will continue to
work with and live among the
Palestinian population as we continue the
work to which Vik was so
committed.
In these days of mourning, Palestinians have
organized numerous
memorials for Vik; they constantly remind us
how sorry they are to
have lost him, of how they loved him, his
closeness, his affection,
and his indignation at what is happening here
in Gaza. We know that
the group that perpetrated this horrible
crime does not in any way
represent Palestinian society. The
Palestinians of Gaza are our
friends, our colleagues, and our reason for
being here; we will
continue to stand by their side.
As we had done when Vittorio was with us, we
will continue to stand
alongside the Palestinian people, we will
continue to struggle against
the occupation, we will continue to accompany
farmers to their lands
along the border, we will continue to
participate in demonstrations,
and we will continue to tell the world what
happens here in the Gaza
Strip, Palestine. We think that Vik
would agree with Che Guevara when
he said, Dont cry for me if I die,
do what I was doing and I will
live on in you. The best way to
honor Vik is to continue the work
that he was doing. In particular we
will soon begin crewing a boat
whose mission is to monitor the violation of
human rights in
Palestinian waters. This boat will have
its maiden voyage on April
20: Vik had strongly backed this project and
he had enthusiastically
participated in its realization.
Vik has been an inspiration to all of us, we
all hope to live up to
his example. In a documentary about him,
Vik said he would have liked
to be remembered by Nelson Mandelas
quote; A victor is merely a
dreamer who never stops dreaming.
Your dreams are our dreams; we
will never forget you, Vik.
Buzek
on the killing of Vittorio Arrigoni in Gaza
Brussels - Friday, April 15, 2011
Commenting on the death of Vittorio
Arrigoni, the President of the European
Parliament Jerzy Buzek stated:
"I condemn the brutal killing of
Vittorio Arrigoni in Gaza in the strongest
terms. This murder is vile, cowardly and
barbaric.
Arrigoni was in Gaza to try to help
Palestinians face their daily hardships; he
had left his family and home country to serve
people in need. His death is a loss not only
to his family and friends, but also to all
those Palestinians whom he was trying to
assist."
We should bear in mind that Israel is
horrified by the tidal wave of Palestinian
solidarity. It is aware of the 40 countries
strong 'breaking the siege Flotilla' that is
planned to embark soon.
Israel is desperate to intimidate us all.
But we are determined. We will keep
fighting. We will expose Israeli crimes and 'tricks'.
We will bring this murderous racist state
down.
It is not clear who killed him: I
personally think that the various Bin
Ladenite kooks and gangs in Gaza are run by
Fath/Israel to sabotage Hamas. But Hamas is
clearly responsible for the lousy mini-police
(non) state that it runs in Gaza. It
has been getting more and more repressive and
people in Gaza (from the ones who write to me)
are so fed up with the Hamas rule. Hamas
should at least conduct a quick investigation
to find and punish those who are responsible,
especially that this is a man who gave his
life to Palestine and the Palestinians.
I looked up his name in my inbox and
saw that the name appears in many emails I
have received on Palestinian matters. And
please, spare me the crocodile tears
of the New York Times: they only put the
story on the front page for purely pro-Israeli
propaganda purposes and to scare off Western
supporters of the Palestinians. Where
was the care of the New York Times when the
Israeli terrorists killed Rachel Corrie. Posted
by As'ad AbuKhalil
You can watch their nasty video here (no
embed) : www.youtube.com/watch?v=kiUknDdhwYE
RB
Palestinians call for release of
Italian activist kidnapped in Gaza ISM, April 14 2011
Today, our friend and colleague, Vittorio
Arrigoni, a journalist and human rights
defender working in the Gaza Strip, was
kidnapped in Gaza. Vittorio has been active
in the Palestine cause for almost 10 years.
For the past two and a half years, he has
been in Gaza with the International
Solidarity Movement, monitoring human rights
violations by Israel, supporting the
Palestinian popular resistance against the
Israeli occupation and disseminating
information about the situation in Gaza to
his home country of Italy. He was aboard the
siege-breaking voyage in 2008 with the Free
Gaza Movement and was incarcerated in Israeli
prisons several times. He was in Gaza
throughout Israels brutal assault (Operation
Cast Lead), assisting medics and reporting to
the world what Israel was doing to the
Palestinian people. He has been arrested
numerous times by Israeli forces for his
participation in Palestinian non-violent
resistance in the West Bank and Gaza. His
last arrest and deportation from the area was
a result of the Israeli confiscation of
Palestinian fishing vessels in Gazan
territorial waters. Vittorio frequently
writes on the issue of Palestine for the
Italian newspaper, IL Manifesto and
Peacereporter. Additionally, he maintains a popular
blog and a Facebook
page. Khalil Shaheen, a friend of
Vittorio and Head of the Economic and Social
Rights Department at the Palestinian Center
for Human Rights, said:
This is outside of our traditions. We
are calling for the immediate release of
my best friend. Vittorio Arrigoni is a
hero of Palestine. He was available
everywhere to support all the poor people,
the victims. Im calling on the
local authorities here in Gaza, and all
security departments, to do their best to
guarantee his safety and immediate
release.
Vittorio was granted honorary citizenship
for his work on promoting the cause of the
Palestinian people. Members of Gazan civil
society are demanding his release; tomorrow
at 4:00pm there will be a mass demonstration
in Jundi Square.
Security officials found the body of an
Italian man who had been abducted in the Gaza
Strip in an abandoned house on Friday, a
Hamas security official said. Two men were
arrested and others were being sought. A
Jihadist Salafi group in the Gaza Strip
aligned with al Qaeda on Thursday had
threatened to execute Vittorio Arigoni by 17:00
local time unless their leader, whom Hamas
arrested last month, was freed.
The body of an Italian pro-Palestinian
activist was found hanging in the home of a
Palestinian militant in the Gaza Strip early
Friday, hours after he was reportedly
kidnapped. Hamas officials reported that the
body of Vittorio Arrigoni, 36, was discovered
in the home of a member of the Monotheism and
Holy War group that claimed responsibility
for the abduction in a video released
Thursday. Two suspects have already been
arrested, and Hamas claims to be searching a
third. The video claiming to show the victim
emerged from Gaza on Thursday afternoon,
teamed with the extremist groups demand
that Hamas release its leader who was
arrested last month. The group threatened to
execute the hostage if it demands were not
met by Friday afternoon. Huwaida Arraf of the
ISM confirmed that the abducted man in the
video appeared to be Arrigoni. Later Thursday,
Hamas police reportedly stormed a Gaza City
apartment and found Arrigonis body. In
a statement, the Hamas Interior Ministry said
the man was killed in an awful
way shortly after he was abducted at
mid-day Thursday. Interior Ministry spokesman
Ehab al-Ghussein said the kidnappers had
planned from the beginning to kill their
victim not to trade him for captives. He also
said that a member of the militant group led
them to the house. An Italian doctor was
reportedly on his way to Gaza from Israel to
identify Arrigonis body. The video
released by the militant group shows a man
with a thick black blindfold and a large
bruise on his face. Apparently seated, he is
held in front of the camera by an unseen
person. In a message on the video, the
extremist group demanded that Hamas free its
leader, arrested in early March, and two
other members whose names had not been
previously known. Sheikh Abu Walid-al-Maqdasi
[sic - RB], the leader of the group,
was arrested in a crowded beachside
neighborhood of Gaza City last month.
COMMENT :
............Jamaat
al-Tawhid wal-Jihad (JTJ) was
founded in Iraq in 2003, and later,
under the leadership of abu Musab al
Zarqawi, changed its name to Tanzim
Qaidat al-Jihad fi Bilad al-Rafidayn
(Organization of al Qaida in
the Country of the Two Rivers).
Abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi was
supposedly the mentor of
Zarqawi, and runs a rather famous
jihadi website, Minbar al-Tawhid
wal-Jihad. Wikipedia has an
entry on him saying he is in a
Jordanian prison. Abu al-Walid al-Maqdisi
is, according to MEMRI, one of
the sheikhs in the fatwa council
created by abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi: http://www.memritv.org/report/en/4191.htm
There is a tendency to blame
Israel for having created or promoted
all or some of these groups at
different times, but the fact is that
Saudi Arabia created and funded all
of them, to outflank the Arab Left,
and Israel, like the West in general,
came along for the ride. One might
argue that Israel is just nasty
enough to counter-balance all these
nasty people, and no nastier,
although parts of the Western media
scene excel at painting the Israelis
as demented thugs and the Arab
guerrillas as misunderstood freedom
fighters. The Israelis do have a
tendency to ham it up, which
doesnt help. Someone ran into
Israeli mercenary Emil Saada at
a dinner party in Massachusetts
sometime in the 1970s and said to him
in the way that one apparently does
at dinner parties, What do you
do and he replied, I kill
people.
I think Said Aburish is the best
writer on Arab affairs I have come
across. He is a Palestinian himself,
and he makes it clear that all the
Arab bosses since Nasser died have
been basically not much different
from western mafiosi. Nasser himself,
however, Aburish has a special
fondness for. He calls him the
last Arab, meaning, I would
take it, the last Arab
nationalist. Aburish very
sensibly lives in Nice, on the French
Riviera, not in Palestine.
Olivier Roy has an interesting
theory about this, to the effect that
Arabs have been unable to form the
idea of nationhood, so there is
nothing between asabiyya (the
clan) and the umma (pan-Islamism).
Olivier Roy recommends a book by a
certain Mohammed Arkoun, called Pour
une critique de la raison Islamique.
Someone discussing this author
noted:
According to Arkoun, the
development of Islamic thought
since the 13th century has led to
an inflation in the number of
things it is impossible to think
about.
This makes
me think again about zionism and
the Jews. As you know, I
argue from time to time that
the Jews are merely a
confessional group, not a nation.
Obviously if this was accepted
zionism would be impossible, which
was the point of asserting it. But
since in fact zionism has constituted
the Jews as a nation, the
weak point of zionism now is that
the Jews simultaneously
claim the right to be nationals of
the various countries of their
diaspora, accusing anyone who
questions the resulting dual
loyalties of being anti-Semitic.
Herzl observed long before the
zionist entity was created that
anti-Semitism would be
its best friend, and it follows from
this that it is in the interest of
zionism to encourage
anti-Semitism in the
diaspora countries, partly by
vociferously condemning it. And it is
this pressure which leads to the
rather distasteful efforts of people
like Philip Weiss to maintain a
Jewish-USAian ethnicity without any
suspicion of zionist dual loyalty
attached to it. So while the Arabs,
and Muslims elsewhere influenced by
Saudi ideology, suffer from an
pernicious negation of nationalism,
Jews suffer from an invidious
duplication of it. But as I suggested
yesterday, this may just be the
cunning of history, which
according to Hegel juggles with all
these categories in an intelligent
and constructive way only apparent to
us in historical retrospect.
By Vittorio Arrigoni
6:05 PM, Marna house, Gaza city
An acrid smell of sulphur
fills the air while the sky is shaken by
earth-shattering rumbles. My ears are now
deaf to the explosions while my eyes are all
out of tears from all the corpses. I stand in
front of Al Shifa hospital, Gaza's main
hospital, and we've just received Israel's
terrible threat that they intend to bomb its
under construction wing. This would be
nothing new, as Wea'm hospital was bombed
just yesterday, along with a medicine
warehouse in Rafah, the Islamic university,
which was also destroyed, along with various
mosques scattered along the Strip. Not to
mention many CIVILIAN structures.
Apparently, they can no longer find "sensible"
targets, the air force and the navy is
killing time targeting places of worship,
schools and hospitals. It's another 9/11
every single hour, every minute around here,
and tomorrow is always a new day of mourning,
always identical to the previous one. You
notice the helicopters and airplanes
constantly overhead, you see a flash, but you're
already a goner and it's too late to take
flight. There are no bunkers against the
bombs in the Strip and no place is really
safe. I can't contact my friends in Rafah,
not even those who live North of Gaza City,
hopefully because the phone lines are
overloaded. Hopefully. I haven't slept in 60
hours, and same goes for every Gazan.
Yesterday three other ISM members and I
spent the entire night at the al Awda
hospital in the Jabalia refugee camp. We were
there because we were fearing the much
dreaded ground raid that never happened. But
the Israeli tanks are posted all along the
Strip's border, and their corpse-hungry
creaks will apparently form a funeral march
tonight. Around 11:30 PM a bomb fell about
800 metres from the hospital, the shock wave
blow several windows apart, injuring the
injured. An ambulance arrived, then they blew
up a mosque, thankfully empty at that time.
Unfortunately, though it actually has nothing
to do with bad luck but with the criminal and
terroristic will to massacre civilians, the
Israeli bomb has also struck the building
adjacent to the mosque, which was also
destroyed. We watched as the tiny bodies of
six little sisters were pulled out of the
rubble five are dead, one is in life-threatening
conditions. They laid the little girls out on
the blackened asphalt, and they looked like
broken dolls, disposed of as they were no
longer usable.
This wasn't a mistake, but a voluntary,
and cynical horror. We're at a toll of 320
dead, more than a thousand wounded and,
according to a doctor at Shifa, 60% of these
are destined to die in the next few hours or
days, after a prolonged agony.There are many
missing, and for the last two days despairing
wives have been searching for their husbands
or children in hospitals, often to no avail.
The morgue is a macabre spectacle. A nurse
told me that after hours of searching, a
Palestinian woman recognised her husband from
his amputated hand. All that's left of her
husband, and the wedding band on her finger
from the eternal love they had sworn one
another. Out of a house inhabited by two
families, very little has remained of their
bodies. They showed their relatives half of
one bust and three legs.
Right now, one of our Free Gaza Movement
boats is leaving the port in Larnaca, Cyprus.
I spoke to my friends on board. They've
heroically amassed medicine and steeped it
everywhere in the boat. It should reach the
port of Gaza tomorrow around 8:00 AM. Here's
to hoping that the port will still exist
after another night of endless bombing. I'll
be in touch with them for the entire night.
Please, someone stop this nightmare.
Choosing to remain silent means somehow
lending support to the genocide unfolding
right now. Shout out your indignation, in
every capital of the "civilised"
world, in every city, in every square,
covering our own screams of pain and terror.
A slice of humanity is dying in pitiful in a
useless listening.
Vittorio Arrigoni is an Italian human
rights activist who is currently in Gaza, one
of a number of activists who arrived with the
Free Gaza
movement. Vittorio (Vik) blogs at Guerrilla
Radio [it], and also writes for the
Italian newspaper Il
Manifesto. His posts vividly
describe what the people of Gaza are
experiencing right now. In one, a doctor
describes the effects of the white phosphorus
shells Israel is accused
of using: He said that what was
totally inexplicable was the total absence of
eyeballs, which even in the case of trauma of
that magnitude should stay in place, at least
traces of them.
In a post on January 8, also published at Il
Manifesto, Vittorio writes:
Take some kittens, some soft little
pussycats, and put them in a box, says
Jamal, a surgeon at Al Shifa hospital, the
main one in Gaza, while a nurse places a
couple of cardboard boxes just in front of us,
covered with spots of blood. Seal the
box, and with all your weight and your
strength jump on it until you hear the bones
crack, and the last miaow is choked. As
I stare at the boxes dumbfounded, the doctor
continues, Now try to imagine what
would happen immediately after a scenario
like that was publicised: the justified
outrage of the world, complaints by animal
welfare organisations The doctor
continues his story, and I cannot remove my
eyes for a moment from those boxes placed at
my feet. Israel has locked up hundreds
of civilians in a school as if in a box,
dozens of children, and then crushed it with
the full brunt of its bombs. And what were
the reactions of the world? Almost nothing.
It would have been better to be born animals,
rather than Palestinians; we would have been
better protected.
At this point, the doctor bends towards
one of the boxes, and opens it in front of me.
Inside are mutilated limbs, arms and legs
from the knee down or entire femurs,
amputated from the injured who had come from
the UN
Fakhura School in Jabalia, more than 50
victims until now. Pretending I had an urgent
phone call, I take my leave of Jamal; in fact,
I head to the toilet, double up, and vomit.
Just before that I was engaged in a
discussion with Dr Abdel, an ophthalmologist,
about the rumours, the uncontrolled reports
which for days have been moving up and down
the Strip, according to which the Israeli
military have been using a hail of non-conventional
weapons, prohibited by the Geneva
Convention. Cluster bombs and white
phosphorus bombs. Exactly the same as the
Tsahal [IDF]
used in the last war in Lebanon, and U.S. Air
Force used in Fallujah, in breach of
international laws. In front of Al Awda
hospital we witnessed and filmed the use of
white phosphorus bombs, about five hundred
metres from where we were, too far away to be
sure that under the Israeli Apaches there
were civilians, but far too close to us.
The Geneva
Treaty of 1980 stipulates that white
phosphorus should not be used directly as a
weapon of war in civilian areas, but only as
a smoke screen or for lighting. There is no
doubt that using this weapon over Gaza, a
strip of land which has the highest
population density in the world, is already a
crime. Dr Abdel told me that Al Shifa
hospital did not have the military and
medical competence to see if some of the
wounds of the corpses they had examined were
actually produced by white phosphorus shells.
But according to him, in twenty years of
working, he had never seen cases of death
such as those brought to the hospital in
recent hours. He described trauma to the
skull, with fractures of the vomer bone, jaw,
cheekbone, lacrimal bone, nasal bone and
palatal bone that would indicate the impact
of an immense force to the face of the victim.
He said that what was totally inexplicable
was the total absence of eyeballs, which even
in the case of trauma of that magnitude
should stay in place, at least traces of them,
inside the skull. However, in Palestinian
hospitals corpses without eyes are arriving,
as if someone had surgically removed them
before delivering them to the coroner.
At the end of the post he says:
I headed back to Al Quds hospital where I
would be with the ambulance service
throughout the night. Riding in one of the
few reckless taxis that still zigzag, defying
the target shooting of the bombs, I saw a
group of filthy kids with patched clothes
standing at a street corner, just like the
shoeshine boys in post-war Italy, who with
slingshots were throwing stones towards the
sky in the direction of a distant and
unapproachable enemy that is playing a game
with their lives. A crazy metaphor that
captured the absurdity of this time and place.
In a post on Janury 10, also published at Il
Manifesto, Vittorio writes about
visiting the hospital again:
Yesterday at Al Shifa hospital I went to
visit Tamim, a reporter who survived an air
bombardment. He told me that he thinks Israel
has adopted the same terrorist techniques as
Al Qaeda, by bombing a building, awaiting the
arrival of journalists and rescue services,
and then dropping another bomb that
slaughters them. In his opinion that is why
there have been many casualties amongst
paramedics and reporters; the nurses around
his bed nodded in agreement. Smiling, Tamim
showed me his stumps. He lost his legs, but
is happy to have made it out alive; his
colleague Mohammed died holding his camera.
The second explosion killed him.
In a post published on January 9, he
explains the importance of the Rafah tunnels:
My toothpaste, toothbrush, razor blades
and shaving foam. The clothes I am wearing,
the syrup to treat a bad cough that has
afflicted me for weeks, the cigarettes bought
for Ahmed, the tobacco for my arghile.
My cell phone, the laptop computer on which I
schizophrenically fight to get out a
testimony of the hell surrounding me.
Everything needed for a humble and dignified
life in Gaza came from Egypt, and arrived on
the shop shelves downtown by passing through
the tunnels. The same tunnels that Israeli F16
fighters have continued to bomb heavily in
the last 12 hours, resulting in the
destruction of thousands of homes near the
Rafah border. A couple of months ago I had
three bad teeth fixed. At the end of the
operation I remember that I asked my
Palestinian dentist where he obtained all the
dental equipment, anaesthetic, syringes,
ceramic crowns, and the tools of the trade.
Slyly, the dentist made a gesture with his
hands: from under the earth. There is no
doubt that explosives and arms also passed
through the tunnels of Rafah, the same that
the resistance is using today to try to stem
the fearful advance of the deadly Israeli
armoured vehicles; but this is small compared
to the tons of consumer goods that flowed
into a Gaza reduced to hunger by a criminal
siege.
He concludes the post by saying:
Gaza has been shrouded sadly in darkness
for ten days; only in hospitals is it
possible to recharge computers and cell
phones, and watch TV with the doctors and
paramedics waiting for an emergency call. We
hear the roars in the distance, and after
some minutes the Arab satellite networks
report exactly where the explosion occurred.
We often watch the pulling of the bodies from
the rubble on the screen, as if it were not
enough to have seen it directly. Last night,
scanning with the remote control I came
across an Israeli channel. They were showing
a festival of traditional music, with lots of
girls in short dresses, and fireworks at the
end. We turned back to our horror, not on the
screen, but in the ambulances. Israel has
every right to laugh and sing, even while it
massacres its neighbour. Palestinians are
only asking to die a different death, one of
old age.
............Jamaat al-Tawhid wal-Jihad (JTJ) was founded in Iraq in 2003, and later, under the leadership of abu Musab al Zarqawi, changed its name to Tanzim Qaidat al-Jihad fi Bilad al-Rafidayn (Organization of al Qaida in the Country of the Two Rivers). Abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi was supposedly the mentor of Zarqawi, and runs a rather famous jihadi website, Minbar al-Tawhid wal-Jihad. Wikipedia has an entry on him saying he is in a Jordanian prison. Abu al-Walid al-Maqdisi is, according to MEMRI, one of the sheikhs in the fatwa council created by abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi:
http://www.memritv.org/report/en/4191.htm
There is a tendency to blame Israel for having created or promoted all or some of these groups at different times, but the fact is that Saudi Arabia created and funded all of them, to outflank the Arab Left, and Israel, like the West in general, came along for the ride. One might argue that Israel is just nasty enough to counter-balance all these nasty people, and no nastier, although parts of the Western media scene excel at painting the Israelis as demented thugs and the Arab guerrillas as misunderstood freedom fighters. The Israelis do have a tendency to ham it up, which doesnt help. Someone ran into Israeli mercenary Emil Saada at a dinner party in Massachusetts sometime in the 1970s and said to him in the way that one apparently does at dinner parties, What do you do and he replied, I kill people.
I think Said Aburish is the best writer on Arab affairs I have come across. He is a Palestinian himself, and he makes it clear that all the Arab bosses since Nasser died have been basically not much different from western mafiosi. Nasser himself, however, Aburish has a special fondness for. He calls him the last Arab, meaning, I would take it, the last Arab nationalist. Aburish very sensibly lives in Nice, on the French Riviera, not in Palestine.
Olivier Roy has an interesting theory about this, to the effect that Arabs have been unable to form the idea of nationhood, so there is nothing between asabiyya (the clan) and the umma (pan-Islamism). Olivier Roy recommends a book by a certain Mohammed Arkoun, called Pour une critique de la raison Islamique. Someone discussing this author noted:
This makes me think again about zionism and the Jews. As you know, I argue from time to time that the Jews are merely a confessional group, not a nation. Obviously if this was accepted zionism would be impossible, which was the point of asserting it. But since in fact zionism has constituted the Jews as a nation, the weak point of zionism now is that the Jews simultaneously claim the right to be nationals of the various countries of their diaspora, accusing anyone who questions the resulting dual loyalties of being anti-Semitic. Herzl observed long before the zionist entity was created that anti-Semitism would be its best friend, and it follows from this that it is in the interest of zionism to encourage anti-Semitism in the diaspora countries, partly by vociferously condemning it. And it is this pressure which leads to the rather distasteful efforts of people like Philip Weiss to maintain a Jewish-USAian ethnicity without any suspicion of zionist dual loyalty attached to it. So while the Arabs, and Muslims elsewhere influenced by Saudi ideology, suffer from an pernicious negation of nationalism, Jews suffer from an invidious duplication of it. But as I suggested yesterday, this may just be the cunning of history, which according to Hegel juggles with all these categories in an intelligent and constructive way only apparent to us in historical retrospect.