THE HANDSTAND

october 2004



A Reckoning With History
The Washington Post Company

By W. Richard West Jr.

    The opening of the National Museum of the American Indian on Tuesday speaks eloquently to the poetic possibilities of history. With this
powerfully symbolic act, the history of the Americas will have circled back
on itself to a point of reckoning and resolution five centuries in the
making. The hemisphere's first citizens will have a commanding presence in
the political center of the nation, occupying the last site on the hallowed
grounds of the Mall next door to the Capitol itself.

I cannot contemplate this long journey through the shadowed valleys of
American history without remembering, as its very personification, the life
of my late Southern Cheyenne father, Dick West. He was born in 1912 in
Darlington, Okla., during the nadir of Southern Cheyenne cultural life. It
had been shattered by the wars of the 19th century and the annihilation of
the great buffalo herds. At 6 he was forcibly removed from his parents' home
and sent to federal boarding schools, where he was dressed in a military
uniform, his long hair was cut and he was prohibited from speaking Cheyenne.
He remained there for the next 15 years and was trained, finally, to be a
bricklayer and carpenter, notwithstanding his obvious gifts as an artist and
his knowledge of traditional Plains art.

Despite these compromised beginnings, my father ultimately triumphed in a
long and productive life, passing away at 83 in 1996, well into my tenure as
director of the National Museum of the American Indian. He remained proudly,
almost fiercely, Cheyenne all his days. In his twenties he worked hard to
graduate from college when most American Indians did not, and later he
became the first Native person to receive a graduate degree in fine arts
from the University of Oklahoma. He became a famed Native artist and major
figure in the 20th-century Native fine arts movement. A college teacher, he
taught generations of Native artists who literally have defined the field in
this century and the one past.

As the museum opening approaches, I often contemplate my father's life as a
profound, indeed defining, example for me. He worked with determination to
ground me in the Cheyenne culture that for him had been retained against the
explicit and oppressive policies of federal "de-culturalization" he had
faced. To honor him and his hard-won wishes for me, I, too, have remained a
Southern Cheyenne all of my life. Two years ago I was asked to join the
Southern Cheyenne Society of Chiefs, which oversees the ceremonial life of
the tribe, and to sit in council where my great-grandfather Thunderbull and
my great-uncle Elliott Flying Coyote sat before me.

But my father also believed, almost adamantly, that I should prepare,
through education, for what he believed would be the future of the Southern
Cheyenne: a future not held back by cultural insularity. After college and
graduate school, I trained as an attorney and represented American Indian
tribes before the courts and Congress for many years before becoming
director of the National Museum of the American Indian a decade and a half
ago.

On a far larger, hemispheric canvas, the museum, through the eyes of Native
peoples themselves, will give voice, in exhibition and program, to these
same stories of cultural challenge, resilience and survival. The stories
tell of enduring values, long held, that have centered the spiritual and
cultural lives of the Native communities of the Americas for the millennia.
They address candidly the devastating impact of the European encounter and
the social and cultural destruction that resulted. They proclaim, however,
with pride and truth looking to the future, the cultural constancy of
21st-century Native communities in the Americas and their steadfast refusal
to become mere ethnographic remnants of ancient histories.

In so doing, the National Museum of the American Indian stands as an
illuminating metaphor for a broader and fundamental change in the cultural
consciousness of the contemporary Americas. That consciousness moves to
recognize and respect the place of Native America as the originating element
of the cultural heritage of all who call themselves citizens of the
Americas. It also begins to honor, at long last, the presence and worthiness
of 40 million contemporary indigenous people and hundreds of Native
communities as essential components of the cultural life and vitality of the
hemisphere.

I regret deeply that my father will not be with me on Tuesday. But in
poignant ways, I know he really is -- because his life of beautiful and
remarkable cultural faith and triumph against daunting odds is the story of
Native America writ large that lives in the heart of this museum.

The writer is director of the National Museum of the American Indian

The Sand Creek Massacre
Southern Cheyenne
November 29, 1864

Governor John Evans of Colorado Territory sought to open up the Cheyenne and Arapaho hunting grounds to white development. The tribes, however, refused to sell their lands and settle on reservations. Evans decided to call out volunteer militiamen under Colonel John Chivington to quell the mounting violence. Evans used isolated incidents of violence as a pretext to order troops into the field under the ambitious, Indian-hating military commander Colonel  Chivington. Though John Chivington had once belonged to the clergy, his compassion for his fellow man didn't extend to the Indians. 

 In the spring of 1864, while the Cival War raged in the east, Chivington launched a campaign of violence against the Cheyenne and their allies, his troops attacking any and all Indians and razing their villages. The Cheyennes, joined by neighboring Arapahos, Sioux, Comanches, and Kiowas in both Colorado and Kansas, went on the defensive warpath. Evans and Chivington reinforced their militia, raising the Third Colorado Calvary of short-term volunteers who referred to themselves as "Hundred Dazers". After a summer of scattered small raids and clashes, white and Indian representatives met at Camp Weld outside of Denver on September 28. No treaties were signed, but the Indians believed that by reporting and camping near army posts, they would be declaring peace and accepting sanctuary. 

Black Kettle was a peace-seeking chief of a band of some 600 Southern Cheyennes  and Arapahos that followed the buffalo along the Arkansas River of Colorado and Kansas. They reported to Fort Lyon and then camped on Sand Creek about 40 miles north.

Shortly afterward, Chivington led a force of about 700 men into Fort Lyon, and gave the garrison notice of his plans for an attack on the Indian encampment. Although he was informed that BlackKettle has already surrendered, Chivington pressed on with what he considered the perfect opportunity to further the cause for Indian extinction. On the morning of November 29, he led his troops, many of them drinking heavily, to Sand Creek and positioned them, along with their four howitzers, around the Indian village. 

Black Kettle, ever trusting, ran up President Lincoln's American flag and a white flag of truce on a large lodge pole in front of his tipi to reassure his people. In response, Chivington raised his arm for the attack.

The main body of Indians fled towards the dry creek bed frantically digging pits in its sandy banks for protection. Those warriors who had been able to grab their weapons engaged in a desperate rear-guard action, killing 8 and wounding 38 of their attackers. White Antelope died in front of his tipi wearing Lincoln's peace medal, his arms folded, singing his death song, "nothing live long, except the earth and the mountains."

Black Kettle and his wife followed the others up the stream bed, his wife being shot in the back and left for dead. The troops kept up their indiscriminate assault for most of the day and many atrocities were committed. One Lieutenant killing and scalping 3 women and 5 children who had surrendered and were screaming for mercy. Finally breaking off their attack they returned to the camp killing all the wounded they could find before mutilating and scalping the dead, including pregnant women, children and babies. They then plundered the tipi's and divided up the Indians horse herd before leaving.


Sand Creek Massacre

The colonel was as thourough as he was heartless. An interpreter living in the village testified, "THEY WERE SCALPED, THEIR BRAINS KNOCKED OUT; THE MEN USED THEIR KNIVES, RIPPED OPEN WOMEN, CLUBBED LITTLE CHILDREN, KNOCKED THEM IN THE HEAD WITH THEIR RIFLE BUTTS, BEAT THEIR BRAINS OUT, MUTILATED THEIR BODIES IN EVERY SENSE OF THE WORD." 

By the end of the one-sided battle as many as 200 Indians, more than half women and children, had been killed and mutilated (some sources put the figure as high as 500). The vast majority of victims were however women and children. Black Kettle's wife although shot 9 times somehow managed to survived the attack. The survivors, over half of whom were wounded, sought refuge in the camp of the Cheyenne Dog Warriors (who had remained opposed to the 'peace' treaty) at Smokey Hill River.

The Colorado volunteers returned to Denver, exhibiting their scalps, to receive a hero's welcome.
Chivington later appeared on a Denver stage where he regaled delighted audiences with his war stories and displayed 100 Indian scalps, including the pubic hairs of women.  Chivington was later denounced in a congressional investigation and forced to resign. When asked at the military inquiry why children had been killed, one of the soldiers quoted Chivington as saying, "NITS MAKE LICE."  Yet the after-the-fact reprimand of the colonel meant nothing to the Indians.

As word of the massacre spread among them via refugees, Indians of the southern and northern plains stiffened in their resolve to resist white encroachment. An avenging wildfire swept the land and peace returned only after a quarter of a century.